In the realm of matrimonial law in India, the terms “alimony” and “maintenance” are often used interchangeably, leading to confusion. However, they are almost synonymous with somewhat similar legal implications and purposes.
Marriage is a foundational institution in society, and while it is often seen as a lifelong commitment, the reality of marital breakdowns has led to an increasing number of divorces in India. With these separations comes the need to address the financial support of the dependent spouse. Two key legal concepts in Indian matrimonial law—alimony and maintenance—are central to this issue.
Alimony
Alimony refers to the financial support that a spouse may be ordered to pay the other spouse at the time of divorce. It is typically a one-time lump sum or a periodic payment that continues for a specified period. It is usually paid before the divorce decree is granted or at the time of final judgment. The primary purpose of alimony is to provide financial support to the spouse who may be at a disadvantage following the dissolution of the marriage.
Maintenance
On the other hand, maintenance encompasses financial support provided to a spouse during the subsistence of the marriage when the spouses are living separately, as periodic payment after the divorce/ judicial separation, or during the continuance of the matrimonial case. Maintenance can also extend to children born out of the marriage, ensuring their financial needs are met. Maintenance aims to provide for the dependent spouse’s and children’s basic needs and livelihood, ensuring they are not left destitute during and after the separation process. Divorce is not an essential element for claiming maintenance.
The Purpose of the Concept
The term ‘alimony,’ which is derived from the Latin term ‘Alimonia,’ means sustenance. In this context, it refers to an allowance or sum of money which a spouse is indebted to pay to a wife to cater to her sustenance. The terms alimony and maintenance are synonymous with each other, and the usage of the names varies according to the different locales. It refers to the financial support offered to a spouse in the event of a divorce or judicial separation. The provision is only extended to the parties whose marriage were legal.
Types of Alimony and Maintenance
Alimony and maintenance are classified into:
- Interim Alimony and Maintenance.
- Permanent Alimony and Maintenance.
Interim Maintenance
Interim maintenance is a provision wherein a husband is obligated to meet the maintenance costs of the wife in the course of the court proceedings. In addition to it, the husband is also required to compensate the cost of court proceedings incurred by the wife.
Permanent Maintenance
This provision takes effect upon the dissolution of marriage or judicial separation, whereby the husband would be required to remit any amount fixed by the court. The time-frame of payment can either be made periodically or on a lump-sum basis. In most cases, the court would require the respondent to make a periodical payment. Lump-sum payments are awarded in cases of mutual party-divorces or when the plaintiff explicitly makes a plea for it. These payments would cease upon the death of either of the spouses or on a date determined by the judge.
Taxability
Any sum received for alimony and maintenance is taxable in the hands of the beneficiary. On the other hand, it is tax-deductible for the payer.
Jurisdiction of the Court
The intervention of the court is triggered when a wife or husband to a marriage files an application seeking permanent alimony or maintenance from the other. The court may, in turn, discreet the respondent to financially support the petitioner for his/her maintenance on a monthly or periodical basis with a sum of money that is decided by the court. The Court may choose to vary, modify or rescind the order given any change in circumstances of either party in the future course of time.
Factors of Consideration
The court determines a plea of permanent alimony and maintenance by taking stock of the assessing income and property of the parties. In this respect, the husband is obligated to provide a full-fledged disclosure of his income and the properties possessed by him if the wife makes an application for maintenance, failing which the wife is entitled to make queries on the alleged omission. On the same page, the wife is also required to make complete disclosures of her income and property details. Besides the aforementioned factor, the court also considers the lifestyle, status, health, age, liabilities, support and education of children and other responsibilities of the parties before making a decree for this purpose. The Indian marriage and divorce laws entitle the wife to receive a sum of money that will enable her to maintain a standard of living which is on par with that of her marital years.
Cancellation or Non-Issue of Alimony
- If the wife earns an income that would enable her to maintain a standard of living which is on par with that of her marital years.
- If the wife has not remained chaste (when the wife is the beneficiary).
- If the husband indulges in an extramarital affair (when the husband is the beneficiary).
Key Differences Between Alimony and Maintenance
| Basis | Alimony | Maintenance |
| Timing | Awarded after the divorce decree. | Can be awarded during the marriage, during separation, or after divorce. |
| Payment Structure | Typically a one-time lump sum payment. | Generally monthly or periodic payments. |
| Duration | Usually awarded as a final settlement post-divorce. | Continues until the financial needs of the dependent spouse or children are met, or until a substantial change in circumstances. |
| Eligibility | Awarded only to a spouse, often the dependent one. | Can be awarded to the spouse and children. |
| Legal Provision | Governed by specific personal laws (e.g., Hindu Marriage Act). | Provided under both personal laws and secular laws (e.g., CrPC, DV Act). |
FAQs
Legal Provisions for Alimony & Maintenance?
Under Hindu Laws:
- Sections 24 and 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: These sections provide for interim and permanent maintenance for spouses. Applies to both spouses.
- Sections 18 and 20 of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956: These sections outline the maintenance rights of wives and children under Hindu law.
Under Muslim Laws:
- Sections 3 & 4 of the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986: This Act provides for the maintenance of Muslim women after divorce.
Under Christian Law:
- Sections 36, 37 & 38 of the Divorce Act of 1869 provide alimony pendente lite (can be claimed by both spouses) and permanent alimony (wife can claim).
Under Parsi Law:
- The Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936 Section 39 provides alimony pendente lite that both spouses can claim. Section 40 deals with Permanent Alimony and Maintenance, which both the spouses can claim.
Under Secular Law:
- Special Marriage Act, 1954 Sections 36 & 37 provide for Alimony pendente lite and Permanent Alimony & Maintenance, whereas the wife can claim both.
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) Section 144 (Previously Cr P C Section 125) – maintenance to wife, children, and parents from any person having sufficient means but neglects/ refuses to maintain.
- Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – Section 20 provides for monetary relief, which also includes maintenance. This maintenance can be in addition to the relief obtained under Sec 144 of BNSS.
Criteria for Determining Alimony and Maintenance?
Alimony
When determining alimony, courts consider several factors, including:
– The income and financial resources of both spouses
– The age, health, and employability of the spouse seeking alimony
– The duration of the marriage
– The standard of living during the marriage
– The contributions of each spouse to the marriage, including non-financial contributions such as homemaking and child-rearing
Kalyan Dey Chowdhury v. Rita Dey Chowdhury (2017) AIR 2017 SUPREME COURT 2383
In Kalyan Dey Chowdhury v. Rita Dey Chowdhury, the Supreme Court held that while determining alimony, both spouses’ financial and social status must be considered. The judgment emphasized that the amount should be fair and just, providing a standard of living comparable to that enjoyed during the marriage.
Maintenance
For maintenance, the courts evaluate:
– The financial needs and requirements of the spouse and children
– The income, assets, and liabilities of the spouse liable to pay maintenance
– The living standard of the dependent spouse and children
– Any reasonable expenses for the education and upbringing of the children
– The conduct of the parties, especially if it involves any form of cruelty or neglect
Manish Jain v. Akanksha Jain AIR 2017 SC 1640
This case concerns maintenance pendente lite, whereas the Supreme Court ordered a reduction of the maintenance pendente lite issued by the lower court. The reasoning given by the court is as follows; “an order for maintenance pendente lite or costs of the proceedings is conditional on the circumstance that the wife or husband who claims the same has no independent income sufficient for her or his support or to meet the necessary expenses of the proceeding. There is no answer to the maintenance claim; only the wife must be educated and able to support herself. Likewise, the financial position of the wife’s parents is also immaterial. The Court must consider the parties’ status, the spouse’s capacity to pay maintenance, and whether the applicant has any independent income sufficient for her or his support. Maintenance is always dependent upon the factual situation; the Court should, therefore, mold the claim for maintenance determining the quantum based on various factors brought before the Court.”
Practice area's of B K Goyal & Co LLP
Income Tax Return Filing | Income Tax Appeal | Income Tax Notice | GST Registration | GST Return Filing | FSSAI Registration | Company Registration | Company Audit | Company Annual Compliance | Income Tax Audit | Nidhi Company Registration| LLP Registration | Accounting in India | NGO Registration | NGO Audit | ESG | BRSR | Private Security Agency | Udyam Registration | Trademark Registration | Copyright Registration | Patent Registration | Import Export Code | Forensic Accounting and Fraud Detection | Section 8 Company | Foreign Company | 80G and 12A Certificate | FCRA Registration |DGGI Cases | Scrutiny Cases | Income Escapement Cases | Search & Seizure | CIT Appeal | ITAT Appeal | Auditors | Internal Audit | Financial Audit | Process Audit | IEC Code | CA Certification | Income Tax Demand Notice | Psara License | FCRA Online
Company Registration Services in major cities of India
Company Registration in Jaipur | Company Registration in Delhi | Company Registration in Pune | Company Registration in Hyderabad | Company Registration in Bangalore | Company Registration in Chennai | Company Registration in Kolkata | Company Registration in Mumbai | Company Registration in India | Company Registration in Gurgaon | Company Registration in Noida | Company Registration in lucknow
Most read resources
tnreginet |rajssp | jharsewa | picme | pmkisan | webland | bonafide certificate | rent agreement format | tax audit applicability | 7/12 online maharasthra | kerala psc registration | antyodaya saral portal | appointment letter format | GST Search Taxpayer | caro 2020 | Challan 280 | itr intimation password | internal audit applicability | preliminiary expenses | mAadhar | e shram card | aaple sarkar portal | epf activation | scrap business | brsr | depreciation on computer | west bengal land registration | traces portal | Directorate general of GST Intelligence | form 16 | rtps | patta chitta
